docs: record the pwsh/bash parity decision and refresh catalogs and bilingual pairs

This commit is contained in:
Huanqi Cao
2026-08-02 14:18:55 +08:00
parent 96cf8a2fbc
commit 4e62fea095
19 changed files with 136 additions and 122 deletions
@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/proposed/feature/2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.md
2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.md: 6f3e48f33d98b2d2da7bd288d42a0d2763163ba3
2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.zh.md: 270fd8d95c85400c302540376932228a6023447c
2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.md: a310174b6864bb880070280835ccfd8623e26342
2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.zh.md: 079c1e3cac789a5e3fa4d0bb889026b3fb69f78c
@@ -6,17 +6,16 @@ English | [中文](2026-08-01-windows-pwsh-default.zh.md)
## Problem
The harness's shipped execution profile is bash-first on every platform. Windows hosts must install a bash shim (WSL or Git-Bash) or fall back to the POSIX-only `dsh-bash-local` behavior; the model-facing bash tool teaches the bash dialect, and the TUI/Web surfaces render terminal output in bash-shaped expectations. The first Windows-native foundation shipped in the [pwsh executor and tool decision](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-01-pwsh-tool-and-executor.md): a PowerShell implementation of the `ctx.bash` seam and a minimal `pwsh` tool — but nothing yet defaults Windows hosts to them.
The harness's shipped execution profile is bash-first on every platform. Windows hosts must install a bash shim (WSL or Git-Bash) or fall back to the POSIX-only `dsh-bash-local` behavior; the model-facing bash tool teaches the bash dialect, and the TUI/Web surfaces render terminal output in bash-shaped expectations. The first Windows-native foundation shipped in the [pwsh executor and tool decision](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-01-pwsh-tool-and-executor.md): a PowerShell implementation of the `ctx.bash` seam and a parity `pwsh` tool — but nothing yet defaults Windows hosts to them.
## Proposal
Three follow-up stages, each independently shippable:
Two follow-up stages, each independently shippable. The former stage 2 (bash-tool parity twin) shipped with the [pwsh tool bash parity decision](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-02-pwsh-tool-bash-parity.md): `tool-pwsh` now mirrors `tool-bash` for foreground and background work minus the sandbox surface, shares the `DSH_*` environment through `dsh-bash-env`, and carries a keyless application snapshot of its assembled surface.
1. **Windows default composition** — the shipped CLI compositions mount `dsh-pwsh-local` as the `ctx.bash` executor and `dsh-tool-pwsh` as the model-facing shell tool on Windows hosts (bash unmounted there), while POSIX hosts keep the bash stack. This is a composition/roster decision in `base.cordis.yml` and the surface overlays, gated by platform; it makes the shipped Windows experience PowerShell-native end to end.
2. **Bash-tool parity twin** — `tool-pwsh` grows the bash tool's missing surface where Windows workflows prove it: `run_in_background` through the generic task runtime, and the persistence-side `DSH_SESSION_JSONL` environment fact. Sandbox escalation stays out until a Windows-confining executor exists.
3. **pwsh TUI/GUI rendering** — the TUI and Web surfaces render pwsh output with PowerShell-aware presentation (native path display, `$env:` facts), the counterpart of the bash terminal cards. This is where terminal/console rendering conventions get a PowerShell twin.
2. **pwsh TUI/GUI rendering** — the TUI and Web surfaces render pwsh output with PowerShell-aware presentation (native path display, `$env:` facts), the counterpart of the bash terminal cards. This is where terminal/console rendering conventions get a PowerShell twin.
The stages are deliberately sequenced: composition first (a Windows user gets PowerShell without choosing), then tool parity, then rendering. Nothing in this proposal changes POSIX behavior.
The stages are deliberately sequenced: composition first (a Windows user gets PowerShell without choosing), then rendering. Nothing in this proposal changes POSIX behavior.
## Alternatives considered
@@ -31,11 +30,10 @@ The stages are deliberately sequenced: composition first (a Windows user gets Po
- A Windows host running the shipped `dsh` TUI/Web gets `pwsh` as its shell tool and PowerShell as the `ctx.bash` executor without configuration, and `bash` is absent from the model-visible roster there.
- POSIX hosts are byte-for-byte unaffected (same roster, same executor).
- The shipped-composition e2es assert the platform-gated roster on both families.
- Stage 2 lands with task-runtime integration tests; stage 3 lands with TUI/Web rendering snapshots for pwsh output.
- Stage 1 lands with the keyless pwsh-tool snapshot already in place from the parity change; stage 2 lands with TUI/Web rendering snapshots for pwsh output.
## Risks
- **Bash-dependent composition rows** — any shipped plugin that assumes `bash` semantics (hook bridges executing shell hooks, workspace tooling) must be audited per stage; the audit may force a staged rollout rather than one switch.
- **Tool-behavior drift** — a minimal `tool-pwsh` that never grows parity invites models to write bash-shaped commands; the prompt guidance and dialect contract mitigate this only if the twin keeps pace.
- **Windows CI coverage gap** — unit coverage runs on Linux; Windows-only regressions in the pwsh stack surface through the Windows build/static lane and e2es, which must be extended per stage rather than assumed.
- **Rendering conventions** — a PowerShell twin for terminal cards is a UI design decision with snapshot surface; deferring it (stage 3) keeps stage 1 shippable without UI churn.
- **Rendering conventions** — a PowerShell twin for terminal cards is a UI design decision with snapshot surface; deferring it (stage 2) keeps stage 1 shippable without UI churn.
@@ -6,17 +6,16 @@ Status: proposed
## 问题
harness 交付的执行画像在每个平台都是 bash 优先。Windows 主机必须安装 bash 垫片(WSL 或 Git-Bash),或退回到仅 POSIX 的 `dsh-bash-local` 行为;面向模型的 bash 工具教的是 bash 方言,TUI/Web 表面以 bash 形状的预期渲染终端输出。第一块 Windows 原生基础已随 [pwsh 执行器与工具决策](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-01-pwsh-tool-and-executor.md) 交付:`ctx.bash` seam 的 PowerShell 实现与最小化的 `pwsh` 工具——但还没有任何东西让 Windows 主机默认使用它们。
harness 交付的执行画像在每个平台都是 bash 优先。Windows 主机必须安装 bash 垫片(WSL 或 Git-Bash),或退回到仅 POSIX 的 `dsh-bash-local` 行为;面向模型的 bash 工具教的是 bash 方言,TUI/Web 表面以 bash 形状的预期渲染终端输出。第一块 Windows 原生基础已随 [pwsh 执行器与工具决策](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-01-pwsh-tool-and-executor.md) 交付:`ctx.bash` seam 的 PowerShell 实现与对等的 `pwsh` 工具——但还没有任何东西让 Windows 主机默认使用它们。
## 提案
三个阶段,各自可独立交付:
两个阶段,各自可独立交付。原阶段 2(bash 工具对等孪生)已随 [pwsh 工具与 bash 对齐决策](../../implemented/feature/2026-08-02-pwsh-tool-bash-parity.md) 交付:`tool-pwsh` 现在在前台与后台工作(减 sandbox 面)上镜像 `tool-bash`,通过 `dsh-bash-env` 共享 `DSH_*` 环境,并携带其组装表面的 keyless 应用快照。
1. **Windows 默认组合**——交付的 CLI 组合在 Windows 主机上挂载 `dsh-pwsh-local` 作为 `ctx.bash` 执行器、`dsh-tool-pwsh` 作为面向模型的 shell 工具(那里不挂载 bash),POSIX 主机保持 bash 栈。这是 `base.cordis.yml` 与 surface 覆盖层里按平台门控的组合/清单决策;它让交付的 Windows 体验端到端 PowerShell 原生。
2. **bash 工具对等孪生**——在 Windows 工作流证明需要的地方,`tool-pwsh` 补齐 bash 工具缺失的表面:经由通用任务运行时的 `run_in_background`,以及持久化侧 `DSH_SESSION_JSONL` 环境实情。在出现 Windows 约束执行器之前,沙箱升级保持缺席。
3. **pwsh TUI/GUI 渲染**——TUI 与 Web 表面以 PowerShell 感知的呈现渲染 pwsh 输出(原生路径显示、`$env:` 实情),即 bash 终端卡片的对应物。这是终端/控制台渲染约定获得 PowerShell 孪生的地方。
2. **pwsh TUI/GUI 渲染**——TUI 与 Web 表面以 PowerShell 感知的呈现渲染 pwsh 输出(原生路径显示、`$env:` 实情),即 bash 终端卡片的对应物。这是终端/控制台渲染约定获得 PowerShell 孪生的地方。
各阶段刻意排序:先组合(Windows 用户无需选择即获得 PowerShell),再工具对等,最后渲染。本提案不改变任何 POSIX 行为。
各阶段刻意排序:先组合(Windows 用户无需选择即获得 PowerShell),再渲染。本提案不改变任何 POSIX 行为。
## 备选方案
@@ -31,11 +30,10 @@ harness 交付的执行画像在每个平台都是 bash 优先。Windows 主机
- 运行交付版 `dsh` TUI/Web 的 Windows 主机无需配置即获得 `pwsh` 作为其 shell 工具、PowerShell 作为 `ctx.bash` 执行器,且那里的模型可见清单中没有 `bash`。
- POSIX 主机逐字节不受影响(清单相同,执行器相同)。
- 交付组合 e2e 在两个平台族上断言按平台门控的清单。
- 阶段 2 附带任务运行时集成测试落地;阶段 3 附带 pwsh 输出的 TUI/Web 渲染快照落地。
- 阶段 1 落地时,parity 变更带来的 keyless pwsh 工具快照已经就位;阶段 2 附带 pwsh 输出的 TUI/Web 渲染快照落地。
## 风险
- **依赖 bash 的组合行**——任何假设 bash 语义的交付插件(执行 shell hooks 的 hooks 桥、工作区工具)必须按阶段审计;审计可能迫使分阶段推出而非一次切换。
- **工具行为漂移**——永远不补齐对等的 `tool-pwsh` 会诱使模型写 bash 形状的命令;只有当孪生跟上节奏时,提示词指导与方言契约才能缓解这一点。
- **Windows CI 覆盖缺口**——单元覆盖在 Linux 上运行;pwsh 栈里仅 Windows 的回归通过 Windows 构建/静态通道与 e2e 浮出,必须按阶段扩展而不是想当然。
- **渲染约定**——终端卡片的 PowerShell 孪生是带快照表面的 UI 设计决策;把它延期(阶段 3)让阶段 1 无需 UI 翻动即可交付。
- **渲染约定**——终端卡片的 PowerShell 孪生是带快照表面的 UI 设计决策;把它延期(阶段 2)让阶段 1 无需 UI 翻动即可交付。