fix(tools): bound the shaped-append side channel; total error containment; recorded spill snapshot

Responding to ds-review-bot round 2 on #661:

- logWork is bounded: past maxParallelSubCalls pending shaped-append tasks
  the ordered commit lane holds (Promise.race drains one), so a slow spill
  backend backpressures the run instead of accumulating unbounded pending
  I/O and retained results. Tasks self-remove on settlement; run
  settlement still drains every task inside the open turn. New spill test
  drives three oversized reads against a hung backend at cap 1 and proves
  the third dispatch cannot start until a save drains.
- shapeDispatchLog's catch uses errorMessage() (total), so a thrown value
  with a throwing toString cannot escape the containment and lose the
  settle event.
- CodeDispatchLog.content documented as the RENDERED result projection
  (native tool/result vocabulary), not what the program received — the
  program gets the structured value; doc pair + type-equiv re-synced.
- New RECORDED tui-agent snapshot scenario code-mode-dispatch-spill: the
  real Loader-visible composition (worker runtime + spill-local + policy)
  drives an oversized bash sub-call end-to-end; replay proves the durable
  dispatch copy is bounded to preview + locator while the program value
  stays whole (the outer result carries just the line count).

Agent Note updated (both languages).
This commit is contained in:
Tianyi Cui
2026-07-26 18:29:09 +08:00
parent 442a3dd884
commit c3c10820ba
14 changed files with 384 additions and 23 deletions
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ Since the full-content dispatch logging landed, a `run_code` program that reads
**A log-shaping waterfall on the registry, and the spill policy as its first listener.**
- **Seam**: `tools/code-dispatch-log` — a scope-filtered waterfall the bridge runs (via `registry.shapeDispatchLog`, contained: a throwing listener falls back to the unshaped content) over each settled sub-dispatch before appending `tool/code-dispatch`. The payload (`CodeDispatchLog`) carries the outer execution, the hoisted `agent` routing key, the sub-call identity, and the default content. Only the durable copy is shapeable — the program already received the complete value across the worker boundary, and the model sees neither.
- **Seam**: `tools/code-dispatch-log` — a scope-filtered waterfall the bridge runs (via `registry.shapeDispatchLog`, contained: a throwing listener falls back to the unshaped content, with total error formatting so a hostile thrown value cannot escape the containment) over each settled sub-dispatch before appending `tool/code-dispatch`. The payload (`CodeDispatchLog`) carries the outer execution, the hoisted `agent` routing key, the sub-call identity, and the default content — the RENDERED result projection a native `tool/result` would carry (the program itself received the structured `value`). Only the durable copy is shapeable; the model sees neither. Shaping runs OFF the program path as tracked side work, but bounded: past `maxParallelSubCalls` pending log tasks the ordered commit lane holds, so a slow spill backend backpressures the run instead of accumulating unbounded pending I/O; run settlement still drains every task inside the open turn.
- **Policy**: `dsh-spill-policy` registers a second arm on the new seam sharing the exact replacement pipeline of its model-facing arm (same `maxInlineBytes` cap, same preview + locator + within-cap invariant, same best-effort fallbacks), with the artifact labeled `dispatch` under the sub-call id. UIs and replay read the full text through the spill artifact exactly as they do for spilled native results, so the native-parity rendering story survives bounding.
- **One deliberate asymmetry**: the model-facing arm skips `read` (the `read → spill → read again` loop); the dispatch-log arm bounds `read` sub-calls too — a log copy is not model context, so the loop cannot happen, and `read` is precisely the tool that produces huge logs.