Turtle
f0410d592d
The web host now composes the sandboxed product path (sandbox-local + sandbox-policy behind bash-sandbox/fs-sandbox, with user-approval and permission on top); BootHostOptions.sandbox carries the deployment defaults (workspace-write + ask). createApiProxy owns the approval pending registry: a ctx.approval ask becomes an answerable approval/requested mux frame with a stable rpcId, replayed verbatim on every mux open until settled; respond routes by the echoed rpcId, validates the ApprovalResponsePayload audit correlation, and broadcasts approval/resolved; the ask's abort signal withdraws the question as cancelled. session.permissions / session.setPermission project ctx.permission into a protocol-owned PermissionOption select; idle switches are held last-write-wins and flushed into the next prompted turn (the ACP bridge's anchoring pattern). The shared hasOpenTurn fold moved to dsh-session, deduplicating the private copies in user-approval, the ACP bridge, and the proxy. Client, per the designer draft: a pending approval takes over the composer (ApprovalPanel replaces the InputBar — amber strip, justification headline, paired command, one-shot refuse/allow, keyed by rpcId so a queued second approval remounts live; the resolved frame restores the composer); the sidebar session row shows an amber waiting-approval dot that outranks the running ring (manager-tracked approvalId set, idempotent under mux-open replays, cleared per connection generation, lit for uninstantiated sessions too); the permission selector is a composer bottom-row chip over an invisible native select, with a presentation-only title-case transform (workspace-write renders as Workspace Write; wire names untouched). Question placeholders stay in the message flow. The connection fixture mirrors the host behavior for keyless browser acceptance.
34 lines
5.8 KiB
Markdown
34 lines
5.8 KiB
Markdown
# Agent Note: Web UI permission presets and approval answering
|
|
|
|
Status: implemented
|
|
|
|
English | [中文](2026-07-23-web-permission-and-approval.zh.md)
|
|
|
|
## Problem
|
|
|
|
The web host booted an unconfined agent: `bootHost` composed `dsh-bash-local` and `dsh-fs-local`, so every web session ran with full file access, no approval channel, and no permission control — while the ACP composition had shipped the complete sandboxed product path (sandbox provider + policy home + confined bash/fs + approval + presets) for months. The web wire contract had already reserved the seats — `approval/requested`/`approval/resolved` mux frames, `POST /api/respond` with `ApprovalResponsePayload`, client-side `pendingBuffers` — but the host `respond` was a stub, no answerer bridged `ctx.approval` to the stream, no RPC exposed the permission select, and the PendingCard rendered approvals as visible-but-unanswerable.
|
|
|
|
## Decision
|
|
|
|
The web host composes the same sandboxed product path as the acp-agent composition: `dsh-sandbox-local`, `dsh-sandbox-policy`, `dsh-bash-sandbox`, `dsh-fs-sandbox`, `dsh-user-approval`, and `dsh-permission`, with `BootHostOptions.sandbox` supplying the deployment defaults (`mode`, default `workspace-write`; `approvalPolicy`, default `ask`).
|
|
|
|
`createApiProxy` owns the approval pending registry. Its `approval/request` waterfall answerer reads the approval id from the session's just-appended `approval/asked` audit event (an ask with no audit event is a foreign channel and delegates), mints one stable rpcId per question, broadcasts the answerable `approval/requested` frame to every open mux stream, and replays still-pending frames verbatim on each mux open — the refresh-recovery baseline the contract already promised. `respond` routes by the echoed rpcId, validates `ApprovalResponsePayload` with the existing zod schema, cross-checks the payload's audit correlation against the routed entry, resolves the answerer, and broadcasts `approval/resolved`; the ask's abort signal withdraws the question as `cancelled`.
|
|
|
|
The permission select rides two new unary RPCs, `session.permissions` and `session.setPermission`, projecting `ctx.permission` into a protocol-owned `PermissionOption` DTO (the ACP bridge precedent: each protocol owns its presentation shape). A permission-less composition serves an empty select and clients hide the control. Idle switches are held last-write-wins in a proxy-side pending map and flushed on `agent/prompt-submit`, because knob events must stay turn-enclosed for durable replay; the shared `hasOpenTurn` fold moved to `dsh-session` and replaced the private copies in `dsh-user-approval`, the ACP bridge, and the proxy.
|
|
|
|
Client-side, `Session` gained `permissions` and `setPermission`, and approval answering rides the runtime's `PendingWait` carrier. Per the designer draft, a pending approval takes over the composer: `ApprovalPanel` registers as a selector-routed entry of the conversation-declared `conversation.composer` chain (the ui-question pattern), replacing the InputBar with the justification headline, the paired command, and one-shot refuse/allow buttons; the `PendingApproval` domain face in ui-conversation's contract owns the `ApprovalResponsePayload` wire encoding over the carrier, and the broadcast resolved frame settles the wait and restores the composer. Question placeholders stay in the message flow. The sidebar mirrors the blocked state with an amber warning dot that outranks the running ring: the manager tracks per-session outstanding approvalIds (idempotent under mux-open replays, cleared per connection generation so the reopen replay is authoritative) rather than reading Session instances, so the dot lights for sessions never instantiated. The composer's bottom-row chip hosts the `PermissionSelect` control fed through the conversation inject face. The connection fixture mirrors the host: its resident approval is answerable once, and its permission select persists per session.
|
|
|
|
## Alternatives considered
|
|
|
|
**Reuse the ACP `session/set_config_option` shape on the web wire.** Rejected: the web contract's unary method registry (`RpcMethodMap` + per-method zod schemas) is its own dialect; a generic config-option surface would bypass the compiler-locked schema table for one select. A dedicated method pair keeps both sides derivable from the signature.
|
|
|
|
**A session event for pending approvals instead of a proxy-side registry.** Rejected: approval requests are transient interaction state, not durable session data — the `approval/asked`/`decided` audit pair already logs the durable half. Persisting requested frames would re-ask dead questions on replay.
|
|
|
|
**Registering the answerer only when a mux subscriber exists.** Rejected: the pending entry must survive client disconnects (refresh recovery is the point), so the registry outlives any one stream; a subscriber-gated answerer would fail asks closed during a reload window.
|
|
|
|
**Optimistic card removal on click.** Rejected: the broadcast resolved frame is the truth; removing on click would hide a question that a rejected receipt or transport failure left standing. The panel disables its buttons locally and re-arms them on failure instead.
|
|
|
|
## Consequences
|
|
|
|
Web sessions now start confined (`workspace-write` + `ask` by default) and a sandbox-denial escalation reaches the browser as an answerable card; the deployment can widen or narrow the default through `BootHostOptions.sandbox` without touching the assembly. Question answering shipped separately through the same registry pattern (ui-question over the question pending table). The permission select reads once per mount; live refresh from another client's switch is deferred. Coverage: proxy registry and permission RPC unit suites, session-object and fixture unit suites, and the keyless web smoke exercises the fixture-mode approval answer and preset switch in a real browser.
|